World’s Best Greek Potatoes

Sep 07, 2020 by


About a year ago, my mom introduced me to a Greek potato recipe she’d discovered through Pinterest. I was immediately drawn to them when I learned the ‘secret ingredient’ was yellow mustard. After sampling the potatoes at a family dinner, I concurred with my mom that they were indeed the most delicious Greek potatoes we had ever tasted! Kudos to recipe developers Mirella and Panos of Little Cooking Tips!

Since then, I’ve made the potatoes over a dozen times. Lately, I’m averaging once a week thanks to pregnancy cravings….they hit the SPOT. Over time, my mom and I have tweaked the method, which we feel improves the end result significantly. The main changes are a significantly crispier potato and a more flavourful one thanks to a quick par-boil and greater quantities of certain ingredients. I’ve shared the instructions on Instagram stories a few times, but I felt it was time to put these details on the blog so they are easily accessible to you. So, here you go: the best lemony Greek potatoes. I highly recommend you double the recipe. When you eat the last one, you WILL wish you had more! Just make sure you have two large casserole dishes (you don’t want to load up a single dish with double the potatoes or they won’t get as crispy).

Ingredients


  • 1kg Russet potatoes (peeled)
  • 2 heaping tbsp minced garlic (~6 cloves)
  • 2 heaping tbsp yellow mustard
  • 1/3 c. fresh squeezed lemon juice
  • 1 heaping tbsp dried oregano
  • 1/2 c. extra virgin olive oil
  • 1 tsp sea salt (plus more when serving)
  • 1 tsp freshly ground pepper
  • 1 tsp baking soda

Directions

  1. The day before you plan to enjoy the potatoes, get started with your prep. You want lots of time for them to marinate! Start by boiling a big pot of water on the stove and peeling your potatoes. Quarter the potatoes length-wise. If some potatoes are extra thick, you may want to cut each quarter in half.
  2. Once your water is boiling, add in 1 tsp of salt and 1 tsp of baking soda, then add in your potatoes and cover with a lid. Immediately, set the timer for two minutes. The cool potatoes will stop the water from boiling, but that’s okay — they are still cooking and getting softer. Once the timer goes, dump the potatoes out into a sieve and rinse with cold water to stop them from cooking further. You don’t want them too soft. Set them aside while you prepare the marinade.
  3. In your large casserole dish (anywhere around 11″ x 9″), mix together olive oil, minced garlic, yellow mustard (like Suzie’s or French’s), lemon juice, oregano, salt and pepper. Add in your potatoes and stir them around until each is fully coated. Cover and place in the fridge overnight. When you have the opportunity, remove them from the fridge and stir the potatoes around so the other sides get to bathe in the marinade (I try to do this at least three times before cooking). You can get away with a very short marinade (1 hour) but I’ve marinated up to 36 hours and they were amazing! I could tell the difference.
  4. When it’s time to cook them, preheat your oven to 390F and cover the dish with an upside down baking sheet (aluminum foil is typically used here but I find a baking sheet works just as well and it’s zero waste). Bake for an hour, then remove the cover and bake for another 45 minutes. Thanks to the baking soda in the boiling water, the bottoms should have an irresistible extra crispy layer. Remove from oven and enjoy with a Greek salad (with this tofu feta)…or all on their own like I do (I actually love them best at room temperature). Sometimes I add an extra drizzle of lemon when they’re on my plate. They’re all I want to eat sometimes!! Hope you love them as much as I do.

Recipe FAQs

Q: How do you get them so crunchy?
A: The baking soda added to the parboil water is the trick! This helps them crisp up during the baking process. Also, I find that they get extra crispy if, when they’re all done baking, I open the oven door, turn the oven off, but leave the bake tray in the oven while they cool. Lastly, don’t flip them at any point during the baking process.

Q: Do you flip them at all during the marination or the cooking process?
A: Marination — yes, I flip them a few times throughout the process. Cooking — never.

Q: What do you think is the best potato to use?
A: I usually go with russet but really loved using a mix of nugget and fingerling potatoes recently! Honestly, I don’t think you can go wrong!

Q: How do I prevent my potatoes from darkening during the marination process?
A: This is totally normal and happens when potatoes that have been boiled are exposed to air. That said, it doesn’t happen with mine — not sure why! I know that this is not appealing visually, but they are fine to eat even if they have darkened.

Q: Have you ever tried them with less oil?
A: I haven’t, but would love to hear how they turned out if you do! To me, they are an indulgence so I don’t focus too much on the fat / sodium when I’m enjoying them.

Q: Do you dip them in anything?
A: No, I don’t. They are so flavourful on their own — they don’t need anything. That said, some vegan tzatziki would be my pick if I had to choose a dipping sauce.

Q: Do you need the baking soda?
A: No, but it definitely helps add crunch to the finished product.

Rating

Rated 5 out of 5
5 out of 5 stars (based on 16 reviews)

Add your own review

Latest Reviews

So good!

Rated 5 out of 5
April 10, 2021

Oh wow, these are unreal! Easy to make yet absolutely delicious every time. Thanks for sharing!

Stacey

Delicious!

Rated 5 out of 5
April 5, 2021

So delicious and addictive! Whole family loves them.

Mel

They are really Perfect!

Rated 5 out of 5
April 3, 2021

I’ve made this 3 times, every time they are perfect, the mustard really makes a difference and boiling them in water is the secret!! Thanks Erin

Aslida

Phenomenal

Rated 5 out of 5
March 28, 2021

These potatoes were hands down the best homemade potatoes I’ve ever had. They brought me back to eating at Olympia Pizza (Greek restaurant in Vancouver) with my family when I was younger. They do take a lot of time to marinate; however, they are SO worth it.

Kiley

Best potatoes ever!!!!

Rated 5 out of 5
March 22, 2021

I’ve made these multiple times now and keep coming back to this recipe – it’s so good!!! I’ve tried different marinating times and the longer the better. You definitely notice a difference if you marinate 24+ hours.

Hayley